Mexico Bay's Best 8-Hour Lake Ontario Fishing

Published Date: July 18, 2025
Fishing

Lake Ontario
$600 - $1,420 price range
Updated Date: October 6, 2025

Summary

Get ready for a full day of fishing on Lake Ontario's Mexico Bay. This 8-hour private charter takes you offshore to target Brown Trout and Chinook Salmon. Whether you're a seasoned angler or new to fishing, the experienced captains will guide you through the best spots and techniques. They'll provide all the gear you need – just bring your New York fishing license and enthusiasm. It's perfect for small groups, families, or friends looking to spend quality time on the water. You'll have plenty of time to explore productive areas and try your luck at landing some of the lake's prized catches. The captains know these waters well and are happy to share their local knowledge. By the end of the day, you'll have gained new fishing skills and hopefully some great catches to show for it.

Mexico Bay's Best 8-Hour Lake Ontario Fishing

Reeling in Lake Ontario

Morning catch today on the Finhooker

Lake Ontario Salmon fishing trip

Spotted weakfish caught while fishing in NY

Trophy Trout from Lake Ontario

Chinook Salmon caught in Mexico Bay

Reel in the Big One on Lake Ontario

Get ready for an epic day of fishing on the beautiful waters of Lake Ontario's Mexico Bay. This full-day private charter is your ticket to hooking monster salmon and trout with the help of seasoned local captains who know these waters like the back of their hand. Whether you're a seasoned angler or it's your first time holding a rod, we've got you covered with all the gear and know-how you need to land the catch of a lifetime.

What to Expect on the Water

As soon as you step aboard our well-equipped charter boat, you'll feel the excitement building. We'll cruise out to the prime fishing grounds of Mexico Bay, where the deep, cool waters are teeming with trophy-sized salmon and trout. Your experienced captain will be on hand to share local insights, demonstrate proper techniques, and make sure everyone in your group of up to four anglers has a blast. With a full eight hours on the water, you'll have plenty of time to try different spots and tactics to maximize your chances of hooking into something big.

Trolling Tactics 101

On this Lake Ontario charter, we'll be using the tried-and-true method of trolling to target those big salmon and trout. If you're new to this technique, don't worry – it's easy to pick up. We'll set up multiple lines with a variety of lures, then slowly cruise through productive areas. The movement of the boat creates the action that drives fish wild. When a fish hits, you'll hear the exciting zing of the line peeling off the reel. That's when the real fun begins! Your captain will be right there to coach you through the fight and help you land that trophy fish. We use top-quality rods, reels, and tackle specifically chosen for Lake Ontario fishing, so you'll have the best tools for the job at hand.

Species You'll Want to Hook

Lake Ontario is home to some seriously impressive fish, and on this trip, we'll be targeting several prized species. Let's break down what you might encounter:

Chinook Salmon: Also known as King Salmon, these are the heavyweights of Lake Ontario. Chinooks can grow to over 30 pounds, and they put up an incredible fight. These silver bullets are known for their powerful runs and acrobatic jumps. Late summer and early fall are prime time for Chinooks, as they start their spawning run.

Coho Salmon: While generally smaller than their Chinook cousins, Cohos are no less exciting to catch. They're known for their aggressive strikes and fast runs. Cohos typically range from 5-10 pounds and are most abundant in the spring and early summer.

Brown Trout: Lake Ontario's brown trout are some of the biggest you'll find anywhere. These golden-bronze beauties can reach 20 pounds or more. They're known for their clever tactics and hard-fighting nature. Spring and fall are excellent times to target browns close to shore.

Rainbow Trout: Also called steelhead when they run up rivers, rainbow trout in Lake Ontario are a blast to catch. They're incredibly acrobatic, often leaping clear out of the water during the fight. You can find rainbows year-round, but spring and fall are particularly good.

Lake Trout: These deep-water denizens are the native trout of Lake Ontario. They can grow to impressive sizes, with 20-pounders not uncommon. Lake trout prefer cooler water, so we often target them in deeper areas or during the cooler months.

Why Anglers Keep Coming Back

There's something special about fishing Lake Ontario that keeps folks coming back year after year. Maybe it's the thrill of battling a chrome-bright salmon as it tries to throw your hook with spectacular jumps. Or perhaps it's the peaceful early morning as the sun rises over the lake, with the anticipation of what the day might bring. For many, it's the chance to spend quality time with family and friends, sharing laughs and creating memories that will last a lifetime. Whatever your reason, this private charter gives you the flexibility to tailor the day to your group's preferences. Want to focus on trophy fish? We've got you covered. Prefer to catch a mix of species? No problem. Your captain will work with you to make sure you have the best possible day on the water.

Top Catches This Season

Lake Ontario has been on fire lately, with anglers pulling in some truly impressive fish. We've seen Chinook salmon pushing the 30-pound mark, brown trout over 20 pounds, and limits of hard-fighting coho salmon. The key to success is knowing where to find the fish and what they're biting on – that's where your captain's local knowledge really pays off. They'll have the latest intel on hot spots and productive lures, giving you the best shot at landing a wall-hanger.

Time to Book Your Spot

If you're itching to experience world-class salmon and trout fishing on Lake Ontario, now's the time to lock in your date. This private charter is perfect for families, groups of friends, or even a corporate outing. With all the gear provided and expert guidance from your captain, it's an ideal way to introduce newcomers to the sport or for experienced anglers to hone their skills. Remember, you'll need a valid New York fishing license, but everything else is taken care of. Don't miss out on the chance to create lasting memories and possibly land the fish of a lifetime. Book your Lake Ontario fishing adventure today and get ready for an unforgettable day on the water!

Learn more about the species

Brown Trout

Brown trout are a favorite target on Lake Ontario, known for their wary nature and hard fights. These fish typically run 5-15 pounds, with some topping 20. You'll find them near shore in spring and fall, moving to deeper, cooler water in summer. Browns are opportunistic feeders, so we catch them year-round. Anglers love targeting them for their challenging nature and tasty, orange-pink flesh. To hook into browns, try trolling with stickbaits or spoons that mimic baitfish. A local trick: when fish are shallow, try long-lining flatfish lures behind the boat. Browns often hit these with aggressive strikes. Whether you're after a trophy or just want to outsmart one of the lake's wiliest fish, brown trout offer a great mix of challenge and reward on Lake Ontario.

Chinook Salmon

Chinook salmon, or kings, are the heavyweight champions of Lake Ontario. These brutes average 15-25 pounds but can top 30. You'll find them in deep, cool water, often near ledges or drop-offs. Late summer through fall is prime time as they stage for their spawning run. Anglers target kings for their bulldogging fights and excellent eating quality. To hook one, try trolling with big flashers and flies or cut bait rigs. A local tip: early mornings and overcast days often produce the best action. When a king hits, hang on tight - their initial runs are powerful enough to pull rods right out of holders. Whether you're after a trophy for the wall or just want to test your arms against one of the lake's strongest fighters, Chinook salmon are a must-catch species on Lake Ontario.

Coho Salmon

Coho salmon, also called silvers, are a blast to catch on Lake Ontario. Averaging 5-10 pounds, these acrobatic fish put up a great fight. You'll find them in the upper part of the water column, often near temperature breaks or structure. Late summer through fall is prime time as cohos stage for their spawning run. Anglers love targeting them for their hard strikes, aerial leaps, and excellent table fare. To hook into some cohos, try trolling with flashy spoons or cut-bait rigs. A local secret: when fish are finicky, downsize your lures and slow your trolling speed. The smaller profile often triggers more bites. Whether you're after a limit for the grill or just want to tangle with some hard-fighting fish, coho salmon are a great species to target on Lake Ontario.

Lake Trout

Lake trout are the deep-water giants of Lake Ontario. These fish can top 20 pounds, with some real monsters lurking in the depths. You'll find them in cold, well-oxygenated water, often suspended over deep basins or near underwater structures. Spring and fall offer the best action as lakers move shallower. Anglers target them for their hard-fighting ability and rich, flavorful meat. To hook into lake trout, we often use downriggers to get lures deep. Try large spoons or cut bait rigs. A local tip: when fish are finicky, try jigging with tube baits right on the bottom. The fluttering action can trigger strikes from stubborn lakers. Whether you're after a trophy for the wall or just want to experience the power of these deep-water bruisers, lake trout are a unique and rewarding catch on Lake Ontario.

Rainbow Trout

Rainbow trout are a favorite among anglers on Lake Ontario. These colorful fighters typically run 20-30 inches and 3-8 pounds. You'll find them in cooler water, often suspended over deeper areas or near structure. Spring and fall are prime seasons, but we catch them year-round. Rainbows put up an acrobatic fight, leaping and running when hooked. Their pink flesh makes for great eating too. To target them, try trolling with spoons or crankbaits that mimic baitfish. A local tip: when you see birds working the surface, there's a good chance rainbows are feeding below. Cast small jigs or flies into the action for some exciting topwater strikes. Whether you're after a trophy or just want to bend a rod, rainbow trout offer consistent action and tasty fillets at the end of the day.

About the Cool Boat

Vehicle Guest Capacity: 6

Manufacturer Name: Mercruiser

Maximum Cruising Speed: 30

Number of Engines: 1

Horsepower per Engine: 300

Ready for some prime Lake Ontario fishing action? Hop aboard our private charter for a full 8-hour day targeting the big ones - Brown Trout and Chinook Salmon. We'll cruise the offshore waters of Mexico Bay, known for its stellar fishing grounds. Don't sweat it if you're new to fishing - our seasoned captains have got your back with tips and support all day long. We provide all the gear, so just bring your New York fishing license and enthusiasm. This trip is perfect for small groups of up to 4, whether you're looking for some family bonding time or a day out with your buddies. With a full day on the water, we'll have plenty of chances to track down those prized catches. Book your spot now and get ready for an awesome day of fishing on beautiful Lake Ontario!

Sitemap