%2Ffit-in%2F250x250%2Fguide_websites%2F1530%2Fimages%2Ffinhooker.png&w=1200&q=100)
Mexico Bay's Elite 6-Hour Lake Ontario Fishing
- Published Date: July 18, 2025
- Fishing
- Lake Ontario
- $600 - $1,420 price range
- Updated Date: October 6, 2025
Summary
%2F%2Fusers%2Fe0e17e2e-2a91-4b89-8ac9-75a6f0a33200%2Fratecard%2F186561349_4078658822217124_6898100320752039057_n.jpg&w=1200&q=75)
Big Catches on Ontario
Huge Chinook Salmon caught trolling in Mexico NY!
Reel in the Big Ones on Lake Ontario
Ready for some serious freshwater action? Join Captain Mike and the Finhooker Charters crew for a six-hour private fishing adventure on Lake Ontario's Mexico Bay. We're talking world-class salmon and trout fishing, folks. Whether you're a seasoned angler or it's your first time wetting a line, we've got you covered with all the gear and know-how to make your day on the water a success. Bring your New York fishing license and your A-game – we'll handle the rest.
What's the Deal?
Picture this: You and up to three buddies, cruising the pristine waters of Mexico Bay, with Lake Ontario stretching out as far as the eye can see. Captain Mike's at the helm, armed with years of local knowledge and a sixth sense for where the fish are biting. We're rigged up for both Brown Trout and Chinook Salmon – two of the lake's heaviest hitters. The boat's decked out with top-notch gear, so no need to lug your own tackle box. Just show up ready to learn, laugh, and hopefully land some lunkers.
Trolling 101
If you've never tried trolling before, you're in for a treat. It's like the chess of fishing – a game of strategy, patience, and sudden bursts of excitement. We'll be setting up multiple lines with different lures and depths, creating a buffet that no self-respecting fish can resist. Captain Mike and the crew will show you the ropes, from setting the drag just right to the art of the perfect hookset when that rod starts to bounce. Don't worry if you're new to this – we love teaching folks the tricks of the trade. And if you're an old pro? Well, get ready to swap some fish tales and maybe learn a new trick or two.
Straight from the Source
"Tough day fishing but out guide made sure we had the best chance at catching fish. Experienced, friendly and focused on our experience." - Mike
The Big Five of Lake Ontario
Rainbow Trout, or "steelhead" as we like to call 'em, are the acrobats of the lake. These silver bullets are known for their spectacular jumps and blistering runs. They average 5-10 pounds, but don't be surprised if you hook into a 15-pounder. Spring and fall are prime time for these beauties, but they can be caught year-round if you know where to look.
Coho Salmon might not be the biggest fish in the lake, but what they lack in size, they make up for in fight. These scrappy 3-8 pounders are a blast on light tackle. They start running in the spring and peak in early summer. If you're after non-stop action, Cohos are your ticket.
Chinook Salmon, aka King Salmon, are the heavyweights of Lake Ontario. These bruisers can top 30 pounds, and when they hit, you'll know it. Late summer and early fall is prime time for Kings, as they bulk up for their spawning run. Landing one of these bad boys is a real feather in any angler's cap.
Brown Trout are the lake's golden opportunity. These beautiful fish are known for their smarts and their selective feeding habits. They're most active in the cooler months, especially spring and fall. Browns in the 5-15 pound range are common, but 20+ pounders aren't unheard of. If you're after a real challenge, these are your fish.
Lake Trout are the native heavyweights of Ontario. These deep-water denizens can live for decades and grow to impressive sizes. We target them in the spring and fall when they move into shallower water. Jigging for Lakers in 100+ feet of water is an experience you won't forget, especially when you're cranking up a 20-pounder from the depths.
Time to Get Your Fish On
Look, there's a reason why anglers from all over flock to Lake Ontario. The fishing here is just that good. And with Finhooker Charters, you're not just getting a boat ride – you're tapping into years of local expertise and a passion for putting clients on fish. We've seen the excitement on folks' faces when they reel in their first King Salmon or watch a Brown Trout explode on a lure. That never gets old for us, and we can't wait to share it with you. So what are you waiting for? The fish are biting, and your spot on the boat is waiting. Give us a call, and let's make some waves (and memories) on Lake Ontario. Trust me, this is one trip you don't want to miss out on.
Customer Review
Guide saves the day
Mike Donovan
March 20, 2024
Learn more about the species
Brown Trout
Brown trout are the crafty residents of Lake Ontario. These golden-brown beauties average 5-10 pounds but can reach 20+. You'll often find them lurking near shore structure, drop-offs, and tributary mouths. Spring and fall offer the best action, but browns bite year-round. Anglers love their wary nature and hard-fighting spirit. For a real thrill, try night fishing when big browns prowl the shallows. To entice a strike, troll or cast minnow-imitating lures. Here's a tip: when browns are picky, switch to live bait like emerald shiners. The challenge of outsmarting these clever trout makes landing one extra satisfying.
Chinook Salmon
Chinook salmon, or kings, are the heavyweight champs of Lake Ontario. These bruisers can top 30 pounds, with 15-20 pounders common. You'll find them in deeper, cooler water, often following bait schools. Late summer and fall are prime, as they bulk up for spawning runs. Anglers prize kings for their powerful fights and rich, flavorful meat. To hook up, try trolling with downriggers using large spoons or cut bait. A local trick: when kings are deep, use dipsy divers to get your lures down without adding weight. The heart-pounding runs and strength of a big king will test your gear and skills - it's an experience you won't forget.
Coho Salmon
Coho salmon, or silvers, are a blast to catch on Lake Ontario. Averaging 8-12 pounds, these acrobatic fighters will test your skills. Look for them in the cooler waters near shore, especially around creek mouths and structure. Late summer through fall is prime time as they stage for their spawning runs. Anglers love cohos for their hard-fighting spirit and excellent table fare. To entice a strike, try trolling with flashy spoons or cut-bait rigs. Here's a local secret: when cohos are finicky, downsizing your lures and slowing your presentation can make all the difference. The satisfaction of landing one of these silvery rockets makes the effort well worth it.
Lake Trout
Lake trout are the deep-water giants of Lake Ontario. These silver-grey beauties can top 20 pounds, with 10-15 pounders common. You'll find them in the coldest, deepest parts of the lake, often suspended over underwater structure. Spring and fall offer the best fishing as they move shallower. Anglers prize lakers for their hard-fighting ability and rich, oily flesh. To connect, try jigging or trolling deep with downriggers. A local secret: when lakers are deep, use glow-in-the-dark lures to attract strikes. The powerful runs and dogged fights of big lake trout will test your arms and your gear.
Rainbow Trout
Rainbow trout are a favorite among anglers here on Lake Ontario. These beauties typically run 20-30 inches and put up an acrobatic fight. You'll find them suspended in cooler water, often near drop-offs or structure. Spring and fall are prime seasons, but we catch them year-round. Rainbows are prized for their tasty pink flesh and sporting battle. To boost your odds, try trolling with flashy spoons or plugs that mimic baitfish. A local tip: when you see jumpers, cast small spinners near the surface - rainbows can't resist chasing them down. Whether you're after a trophy or just want to feel that signature leap and run, these trout deliver serious fun for anglers of all levels.
About the Cool Boat
%2F%2Fusers%2Fe0e17e2e-2a91-4b89-8ac9-75a6f0a33200%2Fboat_picture%2Fscreenshot%2520%2528138%2529.png&w=1200&q=75)
Vehicle Guest Capacity: 6
Manufacturer Name: Mercruiser
Maximum Cruising Speed: 30
Number of Engines: 1
Horsepower per Engine: 300
Tough day fishing but out guide made sure we had the best chance at catching fish. Experienced, friendly and focused on our experience.